|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| December 1990 |
|
|
Employer validly effected early retirements under pension rules; plaintiffs' negligence and deprivation claims dismissed.
Employment law — Pension scheme construction — Early retirement (5 years/age 45) subject to employer's consent — Validity of signed retirement documents — Credibility findings — No negligence; claim dismissed.
|
31 December 1990 |
|
|
27 December 1990 |
|
The applicant's obstructed vision caused the collision; no proof of the respondent's negligence, claim dismissed with costs.
Road traffic — Duty of care of drivers and pedestrians — Burden of proof in negligence claims — Pedestrian obstructed vision running into vehicle — Insufficient evidence of driver negligence; claim dismissed.
|
24 December 1990 |
|
Reporting a theft and fetching police does not alone make the respondent liable for the applicant's false imprisonment.
False imprisonment – employer’s reporting of theft to police – whether reporting and providing transport to police amounts to laying a charge or procuring arrest – evidentiary burden to prove employer caused arrest.
|
24 December 1990 |
| November 1990 |
|
|
|
23 November 1990 |
|
Employer justified in summary dismissal for misconduct; no liability for false imprisonment or defamation.
Employment law – summary dismissal for misconduct – duty to reconcile cash sale receipts; Civil standard of proof – balance of probabilities; False imprisonment – liability where employer orders arrest versus merely reporting facts to police; Defamation – requirement to prove publication and factual basis.
|
6 November 1990 |
| October 1990 |
|
|
|
31 October 1990 |
|
False imprisonment claim dismissed: defendants conveyed suspicions; police acted on their own judgment; accountant acted in course of employment.
False imprisonment – restraint by employer – distinction between directing or procuring an arrest and merely conveying suspicion to police – employer/employee acts in course of employment – assessment of credibility and contemporaneous police correspondence.
|
26 October 1990 |
|
Acknowledgment of service constitutes appearance and, if lodged within twelve months, makes writ renewal unnecessary; renewal application dismissed.
Civil procedure – Writ renewal – Acknowledgment of service – Order 12 Rules 3(1), 3(2), 4, 6(2), and 10 – Effect of acknowledgment as appearance – Belated acknowledgment permitted – Renewal unnecessary if writ served within 12 months – Procedure under Order 3, Rule 6.
|
18 October 1990 |
|
Whether the respondent could assume control of the applicant company; injunction continued, undertaking as to damages ordered.
:[
|
15 October 1990 |
|
Persistent drunkenness and violence by the respondent amounted to legal cruelty, warranting a decree nisi and custody to the petitioner.
Family law — Divorce — Cruelty — Persistent drunkenness and violent conduct constituting legal cruelty; decree nisi granted; custody to petitioner; costs awarded.
|
3 October 1990 |
|
Statutory power to appoint guardians under s.11(a)(i) must be exercised by the High Court in open court, not by a Registrar.
Guardianship jurisdiction – s.11(a)(i) Courts Act – "High Court" means court in banc – Registrar/Master lacks statutory jurisdiction absent Rule of Court – Judge in chambers cannot exercise statutory open-court power – Order 32 (rules 11, 12) and Order 2 cannot circumvent statute.
|
3 October 1990 |
| September 1990 |
|
|
|
27 September 1990 |
| July 1990 |
|
|
|
18 July 1990 |
|
The appellant cannot be ordered to maintain an illegitimate child absent proof of paternity.
Affiliation/maintenance — burden of proof of paternity; absence from hearing — service and Order 19(3)(2) Subordinate Court Rules; illegitimate child maintenance requires proof of paternity.
|
12 July 1990 |
|
Employer validly terminated under an express notice clause but unlawfully deducted alleged loss from employee's bonus.
:[
|
10 July 1990 |
| June 1990 |
|
|
|
28 June 1990 |
|
Court found agreed price K12.50 per bag and dismissed plaintiff's claims for unpaid cash portion and consequential losses.
Contract for sale of goods – disputed price – contemporaneous handwritten memorandum and invoices determine agreed rate; failure to produce debit note/payment-split document undermines later claim; consequential loss too remote – foreseeability (Hadley v Baxendale; Koufos).
|
15 June 1990 |
|
|
15 June 1990 |
|
|
1 June 1990 |
| May 1990 |
|
|
|
18 May 1990 |
|
|
18 May 1990 |
| April 1990 |
|
|
Claims for inducing breach, trespass and conversion dismissed where plaintiff lacked possession and defendant acted on owner's instruction.
Tort — inducement/procurement of breach — knowledge and causal link required; Trespass — action concerns possession not title; Conversion — requires intention to appropriate or assert dominion; removal on owner's instruction may be abatement of nuisance.
|
30 April 1990 |
|
Whether reporting suspected theft to police makes the respondent liable for the applicants' false imprisonment.
False imprisonment; employer liability; distinction between informing police and making a charge; credibility findings; police acting on own judgment.
|
6 April 1990 |
| March 1990 |
|
|
Whether withholding payment for allegedly missing tools was lawful and whether related libel/slander claims were properly pleaded and proved.
Contract/payment — wrongful withholding of payment alleged as set-off for missing tools; Defamation — slander and libel; pleading requirement to identify persons published to; qualified privilege for business communications; Counterclaim for conversion/replacement of tools; Costs — costs follow event but court may deprive successful party for misconduct.
|
16 March 1990 |
|
A single act of gross violence combined with non‑maintenance constituted legal cruelty warranting a decree nisi.
Family law – Divorce – Cruelty – Legal cruelty defined as conduct endangering life, limb or health – Single act of gross physical violence may justify divorce – Failure to maintain as cruelty – Decree nisi granted.
|
8 March 1990 |
|
Whether the respondent lawfully disconnected the applicant's water and is liable for negligence and trespass.
Water services — statutory power to disconnect (Blantyre Water Works Act s18) — wrongful disconnection — negligence in billing/investigation — trespass on premises — strict proof required for special damages (lost rent).
|
8 March 1990 |
| February 1990 |
|
|
A hirer of a crane (including supplied slings and operator) is liable where unfit slings and negligent operation cause damage.
Contract of hire – hiring of crane, operator and slings – duty to supply equipment fit for specified task – vicarious liability for operator’s negligence – failure of lifting slings – negligent continuation despite mechanical defects.
|
15 February 1990 |