Civil Remedies

37 documents
Civil Remedies
  • Filters
  • Years
  • Topics
  • Alphabet
Sort by:
37 documents
Title
Date
The claimant’s late-registered lease was void; earlier registered lease prevails and the trespass claim is dismissed.
Deeds Registration Act – mandatory registration period; late registration renders instrument void – priority of registration under s.8
Trespass – possessory tort; possession ordinarily sufficient but yields to superior registered title. Nemo dat quod non habet – unregistered surrender ineffective; re-grant by minister invalid if prior lease subsists. Res judicata – default judicial review judgment not a merits-based bar; identity of parties and merits required
Limitation – bars affirmative claims but does not preclude defendants relying on historical title defensively
Relief – interlocutory injunction vacated; court-directed survey to demarcate customary land boundaries
Judgment 30 December 2025
Whether the applicant is entitled to continue an interlocutory injunction despite a one-day late filing and alleged non-disclosure and stamping issues.
Interlocutory injunctions – Order 10 Rule 27 (CPR 2017) – American Cyanamid principles – serious question to be tried; adequacy of damages; preservation of status quo – CPR Order 2 cure of irregularity – duty of full and frank disclosure for ex parte relief – equity and unclean hands – effect of unstamped agreements where party treats contract as operative.
Judgment 21 November 2025
The applicant’s application to set aside a default judgment succeeded due to non-service and an arguable defence.
Civil procedure — Setting aside default judgment — Non-service of originating process — Delay in bringing application — Prospects of defence — Prejudice — Vacatur of interlocutory injunction.
Judgment 20 November 2025
Section 100 petition confined to Commission‑decided complaints; one unsigned result sheet found but did not affect election, petition dismissed.
Election law – Section 100 appeal limited to matters decided by the Commission; scope of election petitions; irregularity defined as non‑compliance with the Act; presiding officer’s signature mandatory on result sheets; criminal electoral offences (handouts, unlawful campaigning) are for criminal process and require conviction before affecting election outcome; burden of proof on petitioner on balance of probabilities.
Judgment 11 November 2025
A raped minor’s denial of abortion breached reproductive rights; law and guidelines require considering mental-health grounds for termination.
Gender Equality Act – right to sexual and reproductive health; Penal Code s243 – preservation of life includes mental health; vicarious liability of employer; duty to impart information; Minister’s duty to provide clear clinical guidance; Human Rights Commission enforcement obligations; access to lawful abortion for minors impregnated by sexual violence.
Judgment 28 October 2025
An unwarned shot by a police officer killed an innocent bystander; the police service held vicariously liable, revenue authority not liable.
Police law – use of firearms – duty to give warning, proportionality, and duty to render medical assistance; vicarious liability of police service; revenue authority not vicariously liable; admissibility and limited weight of hearsay in postmortem remarks.
Judgment 19 June 2025
An expired, unrenewed summons served outside the three‑month period is ineffectual and justified striking out the claim.
Civil procedure — validity and service of summons — Order 7 rule 25 (3‑month rule) — Irregularity and cure — Order 2 rules — renewal of summons — strike out — notice of change of legal practitioners not served — interlocutory application falls away.
Judgment 9 May 2025
Court awards K70,000,000 to the applicant for negligent medical treatment causing genital mutilation, including exemplary damages.
:[
Judgment 16 March 2025
High Court reversed conviction entered in absentia for felony; ordered trial to continue upon arrest and plea to amended charges.
Criminal procedure – review – High Court power to call records – Trial in absentia – section 248 CP&EC – felony charges – requirement to issue warrant and bring accused before court – convictions where accused did not plead to amended charge.
Judgment 7 March 2025
Leave to appeal and a stay were dismissed as premature and procedurally incompetent because the High Court judgment remained inchoate.
Civil procedure – inchoate judgment – premature leave to appeal – inchoate judgments not appealable; stay of execution – must first apply to High Court where concurrent jurisdiction exists; SCA jurisdiction invoked after refusal by High Court; procedural competency of applications.
Judgment 22 January 2025
High Court set aside magistrate’s judgment for lack of jurisdiction and ordered respondents to repay sums obtained; costs ordered against respondents’ counsel.
Civil procedure – Jurisdiction of subordinate courts – Cause of action arising in another district – Proceedings and judgments without jurisdiction are null and void – High Court power to set aside subordinate court judgments – Third-party debt/attachment orders – Costs and remedies against counsel.
Judgment 21 November 2024
Court continued stay of execution pending appeal, dismissed disclosure application as otiose, and ordered parties to agree arrangements within 28 days.
Civil procedure – stay of execution pending appeal – discretion guided by interests of justice; disclosure/production of financial documents – otiose and irrelevant where stay already granted; interlocutory directions to agree arrangements.
Judgment 30 October 2024
Stay of execution upheld where registry-caused appeal delay and respondent’s concealment of related conviction negated discharge.
Forfeiture and stay of execution – application to discharge stay for alleged inordinate delay – duty of Registrar/Registry to prepare record of appeal – shortcomings in record not attributable to appellant – concealment of parallel money-laundering conviction involving same seized funds – discretion to refuse relief and award costs.
Judgment 19 June 2024
Applications for stay and enlargement of time dismissed as premature and incompetent for lack of jurisdiction; costs awarded to respondent.
Civil procedure — stay of execution — Applicant must first apply to court below (Order I r.18); stay exceptional and discretionary; Enlargement of time — where order made in chambers leave to appeal required (s.21 SCA Act); Appeals premature before assessment of damages — inchoate judgment; Wrong procedural provision renders application incompetent.
Judgment 19 May 2023
Applicant failed to prove individual entitlement to customary land; trial findings upheld and appeal dismissed with costs.
Land law – Customary land – Communal ownership; chiefs’ power to authorize use under customary law – No individual title. Civil procedure – Burden and standard of proof: balance of probabilities
Evidence – deference to trial court findings
Appeals – abuse of process; dismissal with costs
Judgment 23 July 2018
Occupier of customary land entitled to compensation for loss of use and destroyed crops following State taking.
Land law – Customary land vested in the President – Occupier's entitlement to disturbance/compensation – Non-retroactivity of statutes – Assessment of damages for loss of use and destroyed crops.
Judgment 20 July 2018
An interlocutory injunction was refused where the defendant’s actions were carried out pursuant to an existing court order.
Civil procedure – interlocutory injunctions – exceptional remedy; injunctions ordinarily not granted to restrain acts undertaken pursuant to an extant court order; customary land – Section 25 Land Act – sale of customary land may be void ab initio (relevant to triability).
Judgment 4 July 2018
Court continued interlocutory injunction pending trial, finding serious triable issues and limitation defence premature.
Interlocutory injunction — preservation of status quo — American Cyanamid guidelines; Limitation Act — possession, re-entry and forfeiture; Adequacy of damages in land possession disputes; Serious issue to be tried — disputed facts on title and occupation.
Judgment 21 May 2018
Plaintiffs' claims for road‑works damage dismissed: negligence not proven and claim against authority statute‑barred.
Limitation Act – joinder after expiry of limitation period; negligence – duty of care to properties near road works; res ipsa loquitur inapplicable where cause known; pleadings limit issues (waiver must be pleaded).
Judgment 23 April 2018
Appeal dismissed: lower court's adverse-possession finding upheld; inheritance statute inapplicable where not pleaded.
Land law – adverse possession – uninterrupted occupation and use for over 12 years – limitation statute; Civil procedure – evaluation of evidence and credibility; Pleadings – court confined to issues raised; Deceased Estates Act not applicable where inheritance not pleaded.
Judgment 30 January 2018
A GVH allocation and open development confer permanent usage rights where the owner delays asserting rights.
Customary land – communal ownership – chiefs’ authority to authorize use and occupation – allocation by Group Village Headman – laches/sitting on rights – permanent rights of usage and occupation
Judgment 24 October 2017
General Interpretation Act preserves repealed law and subsidiary Rules, so the Rules of the Supreme Court remain operative and the preliminary objection is dismissed.
Statutory interpretation — Courts (Amendment) Act 2016 — General Interpretation Act (ss.13, 14(1)) — effect of repeal on subsidiary legislation — Rules of Supreme Court remain operative — summary judgment procedure preserved.
Judgment 1 July 2017
Interlocutory injunction continued to protect asserted use-and-occupation rights in customary land pending resolution of disputed authority and jurisdiction.
Customary land — rights to use and occupy (distinct from registered title) — interlocutory injunction — adequacy of damages — balance of convenience — authority of seller and jurisdiction of chief to witness customary land transaction.
Judgment 22 May 2017
Appellate court upheld conviction and concurrent sentences based on recent possession and an unreasonable explanation.
Criminal law – burglary and armed robbery – doctrine of recent possession – possession of stolen property shortly after theft – burden and standard of proof – appellate restraint on sentence interference; concurrent sentences.
Judgment 3 April 2017
Interlocutory injunction continued to preserve status quo in a customary land dispute where damages are inadequate.
Land law - interlocutory injunction; serious issue to be tried; inadequacy of damages for land; balance of convenience; preservation of status quo in customary land disputes
Judgment 12 December 2016
Judgment 27 October 2016
Judgment 13 June 2016
Applicants failed to prove customary entitlement; court found land belonged to respondent and dismissed claim with costs.
Customary land – communal tenure; burden of proof on claimant; RSC Order 113 possession proceedings; Land Act (ss.25,26,30,40) – chiefs’ role and consultation in lease processing; evidentiary weight of chiefs’ agreement and administrative endorsements
Judgment 8 February 2016
Court held parties agreed only to grant use of the mining licence, not its transfer; plaintiffs' claim dismissed, counterclaim granted.
Mines and Minerals — mining licence: 'use' v transfer; contract interpretation — objective approach and surrounding background; agency — licence-holder may use agents (s.43); royalties — contractual obligation and counterclaim; plaintiffs failed to prove breach or loss.
Judgment 3 November 2008
Customary land grants surface use only; government/developer may dig for irrigation but must restore land and compensate for damages.
Customary land — surface user rights only; Ministerial control of sub-soil and minerals (Land Act s.26) — Government/developer permitted to dig and lay irrigation pipes but must refill and compensate for destroyed crops/trees — No right to draw water from project canals — Procedural directions to list objectors, map customary lands and hold joint rights-explanation meeting
Judgment 2 December 2007
Delay after an ex parte interim order and genuine disputes over title made mandatory interlocutory relief inappropriate.
Interlocutory injunctions – ex parte interim relief and subsequent delay – mandatory interlocutory injunctions exercised with caution – balance of convenience – competing title/regularization disputes – adequacy of damages.
Judgment 23 August 2004
Customary land rights are constitutionally protected; eviction requires statutory expropriation procedures and compensation; injunction granted.
Customary land – constitutional protection of property rights – expropriation requires public utility, notice and compensation – Land Act and Land Acquisition Act procedural compliance – Environment Management Act grants locus standi to 'any person' – injunction to prevent environmental degradation
Judgment 10 January 2004
Plaintiff in road-traffic accident awarded K160,000 for pain, suffering and loss of amenities; costs awarded.
Road traffic accident — assessment of damages — medical evidence of bodily injury — pain and suffering and loss of amenities — compensatory principle — award of K160,000 and costs.
Judgment 7 November 2002
Plaintiff awarded K150,000 for pain, loss of amenities and reduced earning capacity after a road traffic injury.
Personal injury – Road traffic accident – Assessment of damages – Pain and suffering and loss of amenities – Loss of earning capacity – Liability established by default judgment – Awards guided by comparable cases and local purchasing power.
Judgment 20 March 2002
Assessment of damages after bus-accident: proved special damages awarded; loss of earning capacity and general damages granted, total K846,466.
Tort — Road accident — Assessment of damages — Proof and particularisation of special damages; distinction between loss of earnings (special) and loss of earning capacity (general); recoverability of cash carried abroad despite Exchange Control regulation; quantum for artificial limb, medical expenses, pain and loss of amenities.
Judgment 18 February 2002
Assessment of personal injury damages, hearsay inadmissibility of medical reports, rejection of vehicle claim due to discharge.
Damages for personal injury – distinction between pecuniary and non-pecuniary losses – assessment by comparison and adjustment for local economic conditions; admissibility of medical reports – hearsay unless doctor called; proof required for special damages; discharge as bar to vehicle claim; interest and exemplary damages not recoverable.
Judgment 13 February 1996
High Court reviewed and reduced a Taxing Master’s increased taxation of a solicitor-and-own-client bill, fixing K6,384.20.
Taxation of costs – Review of Taxing Master’s decision – Solicitor-and-own-client bill – Discretionary awards – Requirement for reasons when varying prior taxation – Admissibility of original bill as a guide.
Judgment 1 December 1986